Event details from: No Longer at the Vanishing Point? International Law and the Analytical Tradition in Jurisprudence

Date
14 November 2013
Time
16:30 – 17:30

Dr. Richard Collins is Lecturer in Law at the University of Sheffield. He holds an LLB (Hons) in Law and an LLM in International Legal Studies. His PhD thesis addressed ‘The Institutional Problem in Modern International law: Form and Function in International Legal Theory’ (University of Sheffield, 2011). His research interests lie in the areas of the history and theory of international law and domestic public law, political theory, jurisprudence and the law of international organizations. Richard is currently visiting researcher at the ACIL.

In his lecture, Richard Collins will address the inseparable – yet uneasy – connection between the two disciplines of modern international law and the analytical tradition in jurisprudence.

Abstract

Modern international law has an inseparable, yet uneasy connection to the analytical tradition in jurisprudence, yet the two have not been easy bedfellows. International lawyers have struggled to find a convincing account of the legality of the object of their study, often retreating into pragmatism, whilst legal theorists have marginalised the study of international law as a result.

In his presentation, Richard Collins will consider recent hopes for a reengagement between the two disciplines, brought about by a growing dissatisfaction with the disciplinary scope and coherence of both fields. In particular, he will draw on recent work by the international lawyer, Patrick Capps, challenging post-Hartian conceptual theory, and instead defending a more purposive, evaluative account of international law. Whilst Collins is sympathetic to this aim, and welcomes the challenge which this and other recent work has posed to the idea of international law as a positive, autonomous legal order, he will show why Capps’ aprioristic account of law in general, and international law in particular, results in an account of legal practice which both distorts reality and, in any event, ends up subordinating the international legal order again as a deviant exception to a more perfect domestic paradigm. Instead, Collins wants to pose the question of whether it is time to abandon the search for a universal concept of law capable of accounting for the myriad forms of legal order existing within and beyond the state.

Location

Faculty of Law, University of Amsterdam

Oudemanhuispoort 4-6, Room A101