Event details from: Non-State Entities as Actors of Protection: Assessing the ‘internal protection alternative’ doctrine from an international law perspective

Date
21 October 2014
Time
12:00 – 13:00

According to the ‘internal protection alternative’, a judge-made doctrine, which has gained significant traction in refugee law scholarship and practice, a State may deny refugee status to a person fleeing an imminent risk of persecution if he or she can resort to alternative protection within the country of origin. Certain jurisdictions have accepted that such alternative protection may be offered by non-state entities, such as tribes, warring factions and armed militias, to the extent that they exercise effective control over part of the territory of the country of origin. What is more, the idea that a non-state entity may under certain circumstances offer protection in refugee law terms has been affirmed in the 2011 EU Qualification Directive (recast).

Taking cue from these developments, the presentation will first trace the lineage of the ‘internal protection alternative’ doctrine and review domestic and international case-law touching on the capacity of non-state actors to provide protection. It is argued that the highly factual and pragmatic take by domestic judges when dealing with refugee cases can be used in order to revisit the relationship between human rights and the power of non-state actors, as well as to unbundle the concept of ‘effective control over territory’ in international law terms.

Location

Faculty of Law, University of Amsterdam

Oudemanhuispoort 4-6, Room A009