What if? Contingent and Counterfactual International Law
ACIL Luncheon Lecture by Ingo Venzke
Event details from: What if? Contingent and Counterfactual International Law
- Date
- 20 January 2015
- Time
- 12:00 – 13:00
Abstract
Various forces conspire in presenting the course international law as something almost necessary. Sure enough, few voices would support a determinist theory of law and legal change. And yet, suggestions that international law might just as well be different trigger the strong reflex of rehearsing the reasons why, after all, it is not. The impulse is to rush towards explanation and to adapt expectations. Counterfactual thinking—thinking counter to the facts—stems itself against that impulse. It goes together with thinking of international law as contingent. Contingency emphasizes different possibilities and reminds that the real remains only possible even if it has become real. Thinking counterfactually stems itself against false necessity, supports explanations that are sensitive to context, and it trains the imagination.
Overall, the presentation and its background project is inspired by rich discussions of counterfactual thinking in other disciplines, above all in historiography, but also in international relations, cognitive sciences and philosophy. While there is a lot of counterfactual thinking in international law already—in the calculation of damages or in establishing causation and responsibility, for instance—it comes with little methodological reflection. What is more, there is so far no counterfactual thinking about international law. The presentation highlights why such way of thinking would be promising and takes first steps into that direction. In a concluding step it will actually do what is suggested by way of a concrete example: What would international economic law look like had the International Trade Organization been established in 1948?
Location
Faculty of Law, University of Amsterdam
Oudemanhuispoort 4-6, Room A009