Smart Mixes in Relation to Forest and Climate Change Governance
Organized within the framework of the research project 'Smart Mixes in relation to Transboundary Environmental Harm'.
Event details from: Smart Mixes in Relation to Forest and Climate Change Governance
- Start date
- 4 February 2015
- End date
- 5 February 2015
This workshop will explore the interactions between international law, domestic law and novel forms of private and hybrid regulation in practice, with a view to identifying optimal combinations of regulatory instruments, or in other words ‘smart instrument mixes’, which bolster the effectiveness of the global environmental governance regime. It will do so by focusing on two intertwined environmental problems: deforestation and climate change.
The increasingly complex nature of transboundary environmental problems, such as global warming, deforestation, fish stock depletion, marine pollution and biodiversity loss, and the risks associated with such problems, pose a fundamental challenge to policy makers worldwide, namely that of enhancing the effectiveness of global environmental governance.
States faced with the need to counter environmental degradation have traditionally resorted to public regulation, including both domestic law and the negotiation and adoption of a multitude of international instruments (comprising international treaties, as well as instruments lacking binding force). Yet, alongside these instruments adopted by States, a constellation of hybrid and private instruments has emerged on all levels of governance, which operates in tandem with international law and which engages a variety of actors in the regulation of transboundary environmental harm. Suffice here to note that private certification initiatives, transnational conservation agreements, debt-for-nature swaps and timber legality partnerships between the EU and developing States co-exist with international and domestic law rules on biodiversity and forests.
Global environmental governance conjures images of fragmentation and polycentricity. The crucial question that emerges is that of the interactions between international law, domestic law and the broader set of private governance instruments in practice. Whilst recent research has suggested the existence of both positive and negative synergies between different instruments, empirical studies remain piecemeal.
The aim of the workshop is threefold:
- Problematisation: to discuss the reasons behind the emergence of private and hybrid governance instruments, the correlation between the effectiveness of different instruments, and finally the viability of private and hybrid governance instruments as a means of shaping and enforcing environmental standards.
- Empirical Stocktaking: to identify patterns of interaction and influence between various categories of instruments (e.g. international treaty law, soft law documents, domestic regulatory instruments, hybrid initiatives, private initiatives) and assess their practical impact. More specifically, the project seeks to identify optimal combinations of governance instruments in respect of specific environmental problems, which have the capacity to bolster the effectiveness of the global environmental regime, or in other terms ‘smart instrument mixes’.
- Conceptualisation: to reflect on how ‘smart instrument mixes’ research can provide input for environmental policy design. Ultimately, the project seeks to synthesize the research and translate the research findings into practical instrument choice and design advice.
The workshop forms part of the wider project Smart Mixes in Relation to Transboundary Environmental Harm, which is jointly carried out by the ACIL, the Erasmus University of Rotterdam and Maastricht University and is funded by the Royal Netherlands Academy of Arts and Sciences (KNAW).
The workshop is closed. For information, please contact Dr. Markos Karavias at M.Karavias@uva.nl.