International Criminal Tribunals and Human Rights Law: Adherence and Contextualization
ACIL Luncheon Lecture by Krit Zeegers
Event details from: International Criminal Tribunals and Human Rights Law: Adherence and Contextualization
- Date
- 15 April 2015
- Time
- 12:00 – 13:00
Abstract
Given their mandate to prosecute persons responsible for the most atrocious of human rights violations, International Criminal Tribunals (ICTs) are generally hailed as welcome enforcers of international human rights law: a new instrument in the toolkit of human rights protectors. However, ICTs investigate, detain, prosecute and try individuals, which are all activities that necessarily entail the potential to infringe upon human rights. Therefore, the question central to the research is whether and how the ICTs have interpreted and applied human rights norms in their procedural practice.
The presentation will present the conclusions of this research. It will set out the two main approaches to the interpretation and application of human rights norms by the ICTs that have been identified: adherence and contextualization. The former speaks for itself and entails the ICTs’ abidance by norms of international human rights law. The latter is more interesting, and entails the adaptation of the ICTs’ interpretation and application of human rights norms to the specific circumstances in which they operate. The presentation will explain why the latter approach can, arguably, be justified, provided that certain conditions are met. To that end, an interpretative framework has been developed that the ICTs could follow to ensure the proper contextualization of human rights norms. As such, it is argued that these two approaches are not mutually exclusive. In particular, it will be explained how true adherence might sometimes only be achieved through proper contextualization.
Location
Faculty of Law, University of Amsterdam
Oudemanhuispoort 4-6, Room A009