Event details from: Institutionalizing State Responsibility: Global Security and UN Organs

Date
14 October 2015
Time
13:00 – 14:30

Abstract

Since 9/11, international organizations have actively devised counterterrorism strategies and frameworks. Of particular interest are the contributions of the UN Security Council (SC) to counterterrorism policy-making, which are increasingly attracting scholarly attention. Through Resolutions 1368 and 1373, the SC unequivocally asserted the right of victim-States to invoke self-defence to counteract terrorism, a posture sometimes construed as enabling States to take unilateral action against terrorist non-State actors.

Consequently, considerable scholarly emphasis has been placed on the SC’s role as legislator, i.e. as creator of primary international legal obligations. For instance, there is no question that Resolution 1373 promulgated general and far-reaching counterterrorism duties of prevention and punishment incumbent upon all States, a revolutionary exercise of its powers given that such obligations were not limited to any geographical area or specific timeframe. However, insufficient scholarly emphasis is placed on the SC’s role as implementer of those legal norms, namely at the second stage of the inquiry when it is time to actually enforce legal obligations. The absence of discourse on this front leaves us with the vital query whether the SC can apply the law of State responsibility (SR), the mechanism invoked to engage States’ legal responsibility for failing to comply with international obligations, and implement legal consequences flowing from its findings of illegality.

Drawing from my current book project with OUP, I will examine the largely unexplored role of SR, if any, in catalyzing or informing the SC’s exercise of its powers when handling global security matters. My objective will be to shed light on whether the institutionalization of this normative scheme – SR being central in international law – can yield interesting policy payoffs in responding to global security threats. In my presentation, I will first offer some remarks on the role and recent development of SR in responding to terrorism. I will then turn to the potential institutionalization of the implementation of SR through UN organs, with critical emphasis on potential SC contributions in counterterrorism contexts.

Indeed, starting from the premise that SR can play an important role in the suppression and prevention of terrorism, the question of enforcement remains elusive. Typically, responsibility flowing from an internationally wrongful act is actuated, and ultimately implemented, through inter-State mechanisms. Moving away from self-help remedies and unilateral countermeasures, however, I will argue that SR for failing to prevent terrorism could be implemented by the SC. In substantiating my claims, I will draw heavily from relevant institutional and State practice. Ultimately, I will attempt to show that advancing SR through the SC could prove to be an interesting counterterrorism policy option. The picture that will emerge is one where the SC can play a role, sometimes determinant, in applying SR norms, a prospect that may be a welcome alternative to unchecked unilateralism.

Vincent-Joël Proulx is Assistant Professor at the National University of Singapore’s Faculty of Law and former Special Assistant to the President of the ICJ.

Location

Faculty of Law, University of Amsterdam

Oudemanhuispoort 4-6, Room A101