Event details from: The direct effect of judgments of international courts

Date
20 October 2015
Time
12:00 – 13:00

Abstract

The PhD project explores the effects granted by different national courts to judgments of international courts. The main research question is whether and under what circumstances domestic courts grant direct effect to judgments of international courts.

The issue of direct effect (self-executingness) is usually raised with regard to treaty law. However, in times of much increased activity of international courts and tribunals, the question of the effects of their decisions has emerged. Direct effect raises profound constitutional questions. These concern the separation of powers and the principles of legality and democracy. Domestic courts are the actors dealing with these complex questions at the intersection of legal orders. They are “servants” to international law within the domestic realm and act as pivotal safeguards for the effectiveness of international law. At the same time, they remain answerable to their own domestic law and can thus be faced with a dilemma.

Against this backdrop, the project aims to study for the first time systematically the practice of domestic courts on this issue. The approach chosen is thus an inductive one. The project tries to find patterns with regard to the methodologies and motivations of domestic courts to grant or deny effect to international judgments and the (constitutional) reasons they bring forward to either accept or resist judgments of international courts. In a second step, the project normatively assesses this practice. One focus lies on the question in which cases contestation against international judgments by domestic courts could possibly be justified.

Location

Faculty of Law, University of Amsterdam

Oudemanhuispoort 4-6, Room A101