Event details from: Inter se agreements in the WTO - Peru Agriculture Products Appellate Body report (ACIL Luncheon)

Date
1 March 2016
Time
12:00 – 13:00

Abstract

The July, 2015 Peru – Agriculture Products case was raised in the WTO by one bilateral free-trade agreement signatory (Guatemala) against the other (Peru), in order to challenge a provision in their own agreement as being contrary to a provision of the WTO Agriculture Agreement. The Appellate Body ruled on the WTO requirements of good faith, and applied VCLT Articles 31(3)(a), 31(3)(c) (General Rule of Interpretation) and Article 41 (Agreements to Modify Multilateral Treaties…’). Reference was also made to the Draft articles on Responsibility of States, Article 20 (Consent) and Article 45 (Loss of the right to invoke responsibility).

During this meeting, experiences will be drawn from other (ACIL) researchers regarding other international law regimes (multilateral or regional) that may have had or could have occasion to deal with inter se agreements, either as subsequent agreements or as modifications. For international economic law, it is considered that examples may be found in bilateral investment treaties interpreting provisions of the ICSID Convention. A general question can also be posed as, how do we interpret multilateral agreements when they are applied in the legal relations between a subset of parties only?

Jim Mathis is Associate Professor and researcher at the ACIL.

Location

Faculty of Law, University of Amsterdam

Oudemanhuispoort 4-6, Room A101

The ACIL regularly organizes Luncheon Meetings at which ACIL researchers and visiting fellows present their research. ACIL Luncheon Meetings are open to all; registration is not required.