Event details from: ACIL Luncheon: Pathways to Justice in a Globalised World - An Assessment of the Justiciability of the Extraterritorial Obligations in the Area of Economic, Social and Cultural Rights

Date
24 September 2018
Time
12:00 – 13:00

Abstract

In the era of neoliberal globalisation, capital and economic activity transcend the borders of States. Relatedly, the enjoyment of human rights has become increasingly contingent on and vulnerable to extraterritorial economic forces. If international human rights law is to protect against such forces, meet the demands of social justice, fulfil its promise of universality, and account for power in a globalised world, human rights obligations must extend beyond the borders of States and reach into all areas of their economic and extraterritorial activities. In light of this imperative, the extra-territorial obligations (‘ETOs’) of States regarding economic, social and cultural rights (‘ESC rights’) are beginning to be developed. However, given the relative immaturity of such developments, it remains to be seen what role judicial and quasi-judicial bodies will have vis-à-vis their enforcement and what means individuals and communities will have to seek justice in a globalised world.

Using the concept of justiciability as a point of departure, this paper will discuss whether and to what extent the ETOs pertaining to ESC rights can and should be adjudicated by judicial and quasi-judicial bodies. Upon analysing the nature of the obligations, institutional concerns vis-à-vis their enforcement and normative arguments regarding their justiciability, it is submitted that there are no conceptual or institutional barriers to the justiciability of ETOs in the area ESC rights and there is a strong normative case that they should be subjected to judicial and quasi-judicial review. Thereafter, the tripartite typology of respect, protect and fulfil will be used to elucidate which dimensions of the ETOs of ESC rights satisfy the practical requirements for justiciability. Separate conclusions will be made for each category of obligations, reflecting the clarity of their content and the ability to establish a violation in concrete cases. It is submitted that each category of ETOs contains justiciable dimensions, and judicial and quasi-judicial bodies are capable of discerning between justiciable and non-justiciable dimensions of ETOs throughout the admissibility and merits stages of proceedings. In light of this conclusion, it is submitted that there are potential pathways for individuals and communities to seek justice for violations of their ESC rights in a globalised world. It is essential such pathways are opened and utilised if we are to import human rights protections into the processes of globalisation.

Attendance

The event is open to the public. Please, register via lawandjustice-fdr@uva.nl

Venue