Summary
As a result of the ongoing war between Russia and Ukraine, the media has recently paid a lot of attention to international humanitarian law (IHL), also known as the law of armed conflict. Nearly every day, the news reports about alleged war crimes, ranging from intentional attacks on civilians, the use of certain weapons, or attacks against nuclear power plants or hospitals, but also alleged violations of the rules governing the treatment of prisoners of war. As has also been reported, the International Criminal Court (ICC) has started an investigation, and the calls are made to set up a separate tribunal to specifically address this conflict. Mr Bartels’s PhD research on the retrospective application of a body of law written to work on the battlefield during international criminal trials is therefore very topical.
This thesis considers the interplay between these two branches of public international law. While the clarification and development of IHL by international criminal courts and tribunals was very welcome, the manner in which it has been applied during international trials was not always correct, and may also be critiqued. In addition, the application of IHL in retrospect, as part of the prosecution and adjudication of alleged war crimes or other international crimes, such as crimes against humanity, is challenging. The scope of application of IHL, for example, has been assessed through a criminal law ‘lens’, leading to a significant broadening of its scope. The resultant expansive application of IHL by international criminal courts and tribunals may actually have a negative impact on the protection of persons under IHL or other bodies of law. Similarly, rulings on questions related to the conduct of hostilities may impact the legal framework governing military operations in times of armed conflict, and thus affect members of the military or indeed other persons working with IHL during conflicts. The thesis critically analyses the case law of war crimes trials before the International Criminal Tribunals for the former Yugoslavia and Rwanda, the Special Court for Sierra Leone, and the ICC. It finds that more attention must be paid to ensure that IHL is correctly applied. Incorrect application, whether intentional or not, to prevent impunity distorts the law. Such distortions may result in a version of IHL that can no longer be applied preventatively on the battlefield.